Sociology and other disciplines: history, political science, economics, criminology and law
Sociology I - Invitation to Sociology · Unit I · Topic 4 of 16 · 5 min read
On this page
Cases checked to exist. Read the judgment before quoting a holding.
Every case cited here has been checked to exist — the citation resolves and names the right parties. The propositions attributed to each case have not been verified line by line against the judgment. Case names link through to the full judgment: read it before quoting a holding in an examination answer, and never carry a proposition from notes into court on trust.
1. The general point
The social sciences share one subject, human behaviour in society, but cut it from different angles. Sociology is the general social science; the others are special sciences dealing with one side of social life. Each borrows data and concepts from sociology and supplies it with material in return.
2. Sociology and history
History records past events in their order of time. Sociology studies present social life and seeks general patterns. G.E. Howard put the link in a phrase: “History is past sociology and sociology is present history.”
- History helps sociology: it supplies material on past institutions and changes — the origin of caste, feudalism, the joint family. Weber’s study of capitalism and Marx’s theory of class both rest on historical evidence. Historical sociology is a branch in its own right.
- Sociology helps history: historians now explain events by their social background — the social causes of the 1857 revolt or of the Reformation. Social history draws on sociological concepts.
| History | Sociology |
|---|---|
| Studies the past | Mainly studies the present |
| Particularising: unique events, dates, persons | Generalising: recurring patterns |
| Concrete | Abstract |
| Descriptive and narrative | Analytical, seeks causal laws |
3. Sociology and political science
Political science studies the state, government, power and political institutions. Sociology studies all social relationships, of which political relationships are one kind.
- Interdependence. The state is a social institution; political behaviour such as voting is shaped by caste, religion, class and region. Political sociology studies exactly this overlap. In India, caste associations, vote banks and the role of religion in elections cannot be explained without sociology. Laws, in turn, change society: abolition of untouchability (Article 17), reservation, land reform.
- Thinkers on both sides. Weber’s types of authority (traditional, charismatic, legal-rational), Marx on the state as an instrument of class rule, and Michels’ iron law of oligarchy belong to both disciplines.
| Political science | Sociology |
|---|---|
| Special science: state and government | General science: society as a whole |
| Studies organised communities (states) | Studies organised and unorganised groups |
| Partly normative: what the state ought to be | Positive: what is |
| Studies man as a political being, conscious activity | Studies man as a social being, conscious and unconscious behaviour |
| Starts from the assumption that man is political | Explains how man became political |
4. Sociology and economics
Economics studies the production, distribution, exchange and consumption of goods and services: man’s effort to satisfy unlimited wants with scarce means. Economic activity is one form of social activity.
- Economics needs sociology: economic behaviour depends on values and institutions. Weber in The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1904–05) argued that Calvinist religious values helped produce modern capitalism. In India, caste once fixed occupation, the joint family affected saving and inheritance, and dowry shapes household spending.
- Sociology needs economics: economic factors shape the family, class and social change. Marx made the economy the base of all social structure; industrialisation broke up the joint family and the jajmani system.
- Overlap: economic sociology, industrial sociology, the sociology of development and poverty studies.
| Economics | Sociology |
|---|---|
| Studies economic activity only | Studies all social activity |
| Treats man as an economic, rational actor | Treats man as a social being moved also by custom and emotion |
| Concepts are measurable: price, income, demand | Many concepts are qualitative: status, values |
| Special and concrete | General and abstract |
5. Sociology and criminology
Criminology studies crime, criminals, causes of crime and the treatment of offenders. It began with the Italian school (Cesare Lombroso’s “born criminal”) but today is largely sociological.
- Durkheim showed that crime is normal in every society and that it reaffirms shared values through punishment.
- Merton’s anomie theory, Edwin Sutherland’s differential association and his concept of white-collar crime, and Howard Becker’s labelling theory are sociological explanations of crime.
- Criminology borrows concepts of deviance, social control and disorganisation; sociology uses crime statistics to measure social disorganisation.
Difference: criminology is narrower and partly applied — it aims at prevention, policing, punishment and reform — while sociology studies deviance as one social process among many.
6. Sociology and law
Law is a body of rules enforced by the state. Sociology treats law as a social institution and a formal agency of social control.
- Law comes from society. Custom is the oldest source of law, and Hindu and Muslim personal laws grew from religious and customary practice. Eugen Ehrlich argued that the centre of legal development lies in society itself, the living law.
- Law changes society. Roscoe Pound saw law as a tool of social engineering. Indian social legislation — the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (amended in 2005 to make daughters coparceners), the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 — was meant to reshape family, caste and gender relations.
- Durkheim linked types of law to types of solidarity: repressive (penal) law in societies of mechanical solidarity, restitutive (civil) law in societies of organic solidarity.
- Sociology of law studies whether laws are obeyed, the gap between law on the books and law in action, and access to justice.
| Law | Sociology |
|---|---|
| Normative: prescribes conduct | Descriptive: studies conduct |
| Backed by state sanction | Studies all sanctions, formal and informal |
| Concerned with rights, duties and remedies | Concerned with relationships and their causes |
How this is examined
Short notes on sociology with political science or with economics (6 to 10 marks) need a definition of each, three points of interdependence and a three-row table of differences. The 16-mark question on political science and history takes both pairs in turn. Law and criminology are the likeliest pairs to appear next, given that this is a law degree.
Now try the real questions: Sociology I - Invitation to Sociology past question papers.