Intellectual property: concept, history and forms - Intellectual Property Rights I

← All Intellectual Property Rights I topics Past papers

On this page

1. Property, and why ideas can be property
2. Industrial and non-industrial property
3. Historical background
4. Why creativity is protected
5. The forms of intellectual property in India
6. Administration
How this is examined

Cases checked to exist. Read the judgment before quoting a holding.

Every case cited here has been checked to exist — the citation resolves and names the right parties. The propositions attributed to each case have not been verified line by line against the judgment. Case names link through to the full judgment: read it before quoting a holding in an examination answer, and never carry a proposition from notes into court on trust.

The examinable core. The opening question of this paper is almost always one of three: “What is intellectual property? Explain the importance of its protection,” “Briefly explain the categories of IPR,” or a short note on one form. Each needs the same four building blocks: why intangibles are treated as property, the industrial / non-industrial split, a short history, and a list of the forms with the Indian statute for each.

1. Property, and why ideas can be property

Property in law is a bundle of rights over a thing, good against the world: the right to use it, to exclude others, and to transfer it. Movable and immovable property are corporeal: one can touch them, and possession of one person excludes another. Intellectual property is incorporeal. It is a right over a product of the mind — an invention, a brand, a book, a design — and the law creates the right of exclusion because the thing itself cannot be fenced. Anyone who learns an idea can use it without depriving the creator of it, so without legal protection the creator has no means to recover what he spent in making it.

Three features follow from this and are worth putting in every answer.

It is a negative right. A patent or trade mark registration is mainly a right to prevent others from making, using or selling. Section 48 of the Patents Act, 1970 is drafted in exactly those terms.
It is territorial. A right granted in India is enforceable only in India. This is why international conventions (Unit V) exist.
Most forms are limited in time. A patent lasts twenty years; copyright lasts for the author’s life plus sixty years. Trade marks and geographical indications last ten years at a time but can be renewed indefinitely, because they protect identity, not creativity.

2. Industrial and non-industrial property

The traditional division comes from the two nineteenth-century conventions.

Industrial property is the field of the Paris Convention, 1883. Article 1(2) lists patents, utility models, industrial designs, trade marks, service marks, trade names, indications of source or appellations of origin, and the repression of unfair competition. These rights attach to trade and industry.
Non-industrial property is chiefly copyright and related rights, the field of the Berne Convention, 1886: literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, films and sound recordings, and the neighbouring rights of performers and broadcasters.

The division is now one of convenience. Computer programmes are protected as literary works but are plainly industrial; plant varieties and semiconductor layouts fit neither box neatly. The TRIPS Agreement treats all of them together as “intellectual property”.

3. Historical background

Venice, 1474. The Venetian statute is usually cited as the first patent law: ten years’ protection for new and ingenious devices, on condition that they were reduced to practice.
England, 1623. The Statute of Monopolies abolished royal monopolies but kept grants for “the sole working or making of any manner of new manufactures” to the true and first inventor for fourteen years. The phrase “true and first inventor” survives in section 6 of the Indian Act.
Copyright. The Statute of Anne, 1710, gave authors, not printers, the right to copy books for a fixed term.
India. Act VI of 1856 granted exclusive privileges to inventors; the Indian Patents and Designs Act, 1911 followed. After the Ayyangar Committee report (1959) Parliament enacted the Patents Act, 1970, which allowed only process patents for food, medicines and chemicals. Trade marks were governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1940, then the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, and now the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
International. Paris (1883), Berne (1886), the Madrid Agreement (1891), the WIPO Convention (1967), the PCT (1970) and finally the TRIPS Agreement, 1994, annexed to the WTO Agreement, which made minimum standards binding and enforceable through WTO dispute settlement. India’s present IP statutes were largely enacted or amended between 1999 and 2005 to comply with TRIPS.

4. Why creativity is protected

Examiners asking about the “importance of protection” want the theories, then the practical reasons.

Labour theory (Locke). A person who mixes his labour with something makes it his. The inventor or author has earned the fruit.
Personality theory (Hegel). A work is an expression of its creator’s personality; this explains moral rights in copyright.
Incentive or utilitarian theory. Without exclusivity, copying is cheaper than creating, so too little would be created. A limited monopoly is the price society pays for innovation.
Social contract (disclosure) theory. For patents in particular, the inventor gets twenty years of exclusivity in return for publishing the invention in a complete specification, so that the public may use it freely after expiry.

The practical reasons follow: protection encourages investment in research, allows technology to be licensed and transferred, protects consumers from deception (trade marks and GIs), rewards traditional communities (GIs), attracts foreign investment, and is a condition of WTO membership. The counter-point, which a good answer mentions in one line, is access: patents can raise the price of medicines, which is why the Indian Act contains section 3(d), compulsory licensing and government use.

5. The forms of intellectual property in India

Patents — inventions; Patents Act, 1970; twenty years.
Trade marks — brands, logos, shapes, colours, service marks; Trade Marks Act, 1999; ten years, renewable.
Copyright and related rights — Copyright Act, 1957 (substantially amended in 2012).
Industrial designs — shape, configuration, pattern or ornament applied to an article; Designs Act, 2000; ten years, extendable by five.
Geographical indications — Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999; ten years, renewable.
Semiconductor integrated circuit layout-designs — Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000.
Plant varieties and farmers’ rights — Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights Act, 2001.
Biological resources and traditional knowledge — Biological Diversity Act, 2002; and the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library, set up after the turmeric and neem patent controversies.
Trade secrets and confidential information — no statute; protected by contract and the equitable action for breach of confidence.

Know which paper covers what. This paper (IPR I) covers patents, trade marks, cyber IP, geographical indications and the Paris, PCT, Madrid and WIPO instruments. Copyright and designs are mentioned here only as forms of IP and, in Unit III, as the way software is protected. Do not spend an IPR I answer explaining the Copyright Act in detail.

6. Administration

Patents, designs, trade marks and geographical indications are administered by the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks under the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade. The Controller General is also the Registrar of Trade Marks (section 3, Trade Marks Act) and the Registrar of Geographical Indications (section 3, GI Act). Appeals from these authorities lay to the Intellectual Property Appellate Board until the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 abolished it with effect from 4 April 2021; appeals and rectification petitions now go to the High Court.

How this is examined

Every recent paper opens Unit I with it. January 2026 asked “What is an intellectual property? Explain the importance of protection of Intellectual Property Rights”; February 2025 asked “Briefly explain the categories of Intellectual Property Rights.” For the first, give the concept (section 1), the theories and practical reasons (section 4), and close with the access counter-point. For the second, give the industrial / non-industrial split and then the list in section 5 with the statute and term for each; a two-line description per form is enough. A sentence on TRIPS and one on the abolition of the IPAB show that the answer is current.